Funded in the context of
Beethoven CLASSIC 4
Polish-German Funding Initiative
Funding period: 9/2022-8/2025
Polish Principal Investigator
▍
Prof. Dr. hab. Marzenna Czerniak-Drożdżowicz
Jagiellonian University in Cracow,
Philology Faculty,
Institute of Oriental Studies,
Department of Languages and Cultures of India and South Asia
German Principal Investigator
▍
Prof. Dr.Ute Hüsken
Heidelberg University,
South Asia Institute,
Department Cultural and Religious History of South Asia,
Faculty of Philosophy
RESEARCH TEAM
▍
Dr. Ewa Dębicka-Borek
Philology Faculty, Jagiellonian University
▍
Dr. Olga Nowicka
Philology Faculty, Jagiellonian University
▍
Dr. Ofer Peres
South Asia Institute, Heidelberg University
▍
Dr. R. Sathyanarayanan
EFEO, Pondicherry
The project South Indian Temples: Nodal Points in Webs of Connections consists of five subprojects conducted in close cooperation by a German and a Polish team. All subprojects investigate Hindu temples as nodal points within webs of connections between sacred sites in South India, facilitating a new understanding of South Indian temples as participating in relationships with each other, rather than stand-alone monuments. These temple networks will be investigated in their transregional, regional, and local dimensions. Since the subprojects’ networks overlap with each other, and since individual temples are embedded in multiple temple networks, the project team will be able to view them from different perspectives.
Firmly based in the mythological narratives of the textual genre of temple legends (māhātmyas/sthalapurāṇas) in Sanskrit and in South Indian languages as primary source material, the project includes also the analysis of the same narratives’ ritual performances, and material and artistic expressions, such as murals in temples, reliefs, or statues. Conceptually, the project will look into these narratives from the point of view of spatial theories common for literary and cultural studies, e.g. literary cartography which is based on the idea of a mapping narrative (e.g. Tally 2014), as well as of ethno-Indology, which integrates philology, anthropology and ritual studies to investigate texts in conjunction with artistic expressions and ritual performances (e.g. Michaels 2004).
The main questions that the project seeks to answer are: Do the networks laid out in the texts inform pilgrimage practice? Are observable pilgrimage circuits, which connect temples, authorized by textual sources? What is the relationship between temples at the center, and temples at the periphery within such networks? What are the strategies of establishing links, how are these links articulated in various media (texts, iconography, rituals), how do these aspects differ in different regions of South India (Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh) and how are these strategies differently articulated in various languages (Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu)? Why and when do networks of temples appear, or disappear? Who are the agents behind such processes? By focusing on the dynamics between Hindu temples and sacred sites, the project will contribute to a new understanding of the role of mythological narratives as mapping space in the South Asian context.
This case study will cover two main paths:
Many South Indian temples are not part of just one, but of a number of networks, attesting to rivaling or parallel perceptions and constructions of sacred space. While in many cases these diverse layers of sacred space(s) are not in direct conflict with each other (see Hüsken 2017), economic resources are distributed differently, not the least through the agency of the corresponding pilgrimage routes. In this way, different networks can profit from each other, but also might be in conflict with each other. This relationship between temples and their networks is therefore contested and, over time, undoubtedly very dynamic.
This subproject takes as its starting point those temples which are simultaneously part of two distinct sectarian networks. These are investigated on three levels: local, regional, and transregional. The temples are on the one hand part of the network of “108 (Vaiṣṇava) divine places” (divyadeśa), and at the same time they are situated in or close to the places where the “five (Śaiva) elemental liṅgas” (pañcabhūtaliṅga) are situated. This subproject will investigate the connections between these two temple networks, which converge at specific places, by starting at the sites of the pañcabhūtaliṅgas (Kanchipuram, Srirangam, Chidambaram, Kalahasti, and Tiruvannamalai; see Eck 2012: 253–256), yet focusing not on the Śaiva temples and their Tamil sthalapurāṇas, but rather investigating the Vaiṣṇava sites that are listed as part of the 108-divyadeśa-network and their representations. Three of the five places with a pañcabhūtaliṅga are also home to one prominent divyadeśa (these are Srirangam, Kanchipuram, Chidambaram), and one pañcabhūtaliṅga-location (Kalahasti) is not more than 35 km apart from the maybe most important divyadeśa in contemporary times, the Veṅkaṭanātha temple on the Tirumala hill in Tirupati, which is of enormous regional and transregional relevance. The fifth pañcabhūtaliṅga-location (Tiruvannamalai) stands out insofar, as there is not even one Viṣṇu temple in the entire town, which is extremely rare and can serve as a test case for the other four sites, where the sacred space is shared between these two sectarian traditions.
This case study concerns the issue of temples’ interconnectedness in regard to the complex of Narasiṃha shrines in Ahobilam (Kurnool district, Andhra Pradesh), administered by the Ahobila maṭha. Despite hosting ten temples of Narasiṃha, each representing different, locally rooted aspect of the god, the site is traditionally known as the site of nine Narasiṃhas (navanarasiṃhakṣetra). This path of the project will focus on several so far undiscussed aspects of Ahobilam’s involvement in various relations shared with other temples/religious centers of the region and beyond, as well as on its internal web of connections between individual Narasiṃha shrines in Ahobilam. Such an approach seems crucial for filling the gaps in our knowledge of Ahobilam’s role on the pilgrimage and political map of South India.
The subproject investigates the arithmetic and algebra of place (Feldhaus 2003) based on the example of the nālampalam – the Vaiṣṇava temple clusters of Kerala.
Nālampalam (from Malayalam “four temples”) is the concept of cluster of four temples dedicated to the sons of Daśaratha – Rāma, Lakṣmaṇa, Bharata and Śatrughna. The most famous cluster consists of the Śrī Rāmasvāmi temple in Tṛprayār, Kūṭalmāṇikyam temple dedicated to Bharata in Iriññālakkuṭa, Śrī Lakṣmaṇapperumāḷ temple in Mūḻikkuḷam, and Śatrughna temple in Pāyammal (Vaidyanathan 2011, 123-134). The temples have adopted a particular pilgrimage pattern (nālampala-darśanam) that prescribes to visit all shrines during one day in the Karkkaṭakam month (July-August) – also referred to as Rāmāyaṇa māsam “Rāmāyaṇa month” in Kerala. Apart from the above mentioned temples, there are said to be at least three more sets of nālampalam that are located across the state of Kerala.
The case study aims at paying particular attention to the issues that appears to come to the forefront while examining the nālampalam phenomenon i.e. the arithmetic and algebra of place (Feldhaus 2003). Within the framework of the project analysis, the arithmetic of place shall concern the creation of the numbered sets of places and their multiplication, while the algebra of place shall refer to the geography replication and relations between the particular elements of the discussed groups/sets of places (Feldhaus 2003).
Feldhaus, A. 2003. Connected Places. Region, Pilgrimage, and Geographical Imagination in India. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Vaidyanathan, K.R. 1982. Temples and Legends of Kerala. Bombay: Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan.
Murukaṉ is an ancient Tamil divinity, referred to in some of the earliest Tamil texts of the Sangam period. Although identified as Śiva’s son (Skanda) in the orthodox Hindu system, in south India Murukaṉ is considered an independent divinity and a primary God by his followers. The Murukan cult is one of the largest and most popular cults in Tamil Nadu, with many temples that serve as popular pilgrimage centers. Among them, a group of six temples, conventionally called āṟupaṭaivīṭu (“the six army camps”), are considered the biggest and most important pilgrimage sites for Murukaṉ devotees. Each of these temples, located in various parts of the Tamil region, is related to a specific episode in Murukaṉ’s biography, and each has its own practices and ritual cycle.
This project examines the six sites (Tirupparaṅkuṉṟam, Tiruccentūr, Paḻaṉi, Tiruvērakam, Triruttaṇi, and Paḻamutircolai) through their interrelations, attending to the following questions: how did the notion of the āṟupaṭaivīṭu, that is, of six distinguished sites favored by Murukaṉ, manifest in these six specific geographic sites known today? When and by whom was their identification determined? How was the mythological relationship between the six temples realized in pre-modern times, specifically in their designated “temple legends” (talapurāṇams) and other devotional literature composed in their honor? What kind of modifications take place in the conception of the relationship between each site with regard to the others? How are the six sites related ritually, based on contemporary temple practices? By addressing these issues, I aim to provide a better understanding of the processes that bring to the consolidation of religious sites in fixed sets.
Venue:
Institute of Oriental Studies, Collegium Paderevianum, Al. Mickiewicza 9, 2nd floor, rooms 210, 205 and 206
With presentations by
Ute Huesken, Ofer Peres, Ewa Dębicka-Borek, Jonas Buchholz, Olga Nowicka (online), Marzenna Czerniak-Drożdżowicz and R. Sathyanarayanan
On July 22nd-24th 2023, the project members convened in Heidelberg for a three-day workshop, to reflect on the first year of our activity. In the workshop, each member presented her or his findings and progress. We exchanged ideas on theoretical and methodological frameworks and discussed the overlaps between our separate works and their implications on the general study of sacred places. We were excited and honored to have with us as a guest speaker and discussant Ann Feldhaus, a Distinguished Foundation Professor of Religious Studies (Emeritus) at Arizona State University and an expert on the religious traditions of Maharashtra. Professor Feldhaus gave a talk on her own new project and provided feedback on the project’s presentations. In the concluding discussion, the project member formed the outline of our first planned edited volume.
On July 26th, the project members met again, this time in Turin, for the 27th European Conference on South Asian Studies (ECSAS). In the conference, which was hosted in University of Turin’s Campus Luigi Einaudi, the SITes project organized a three-session panel titled “South Asian sacred spots: Nodal Points in Webs of Connections.” The participants included, alongside the project members, eight scholars from North America, Europe, and Asia, working on a range of aspects related to sacred sites in various parts of South Asia.
KONTAKT | CONTACT
Sekretariat | Office
Lizeth Ortiz-Carreño
Mon. & Wed. 09:00 - 17 Hrs.
Fri. 13-17 Hrs. (Home Office)
Voßstrasse 2 • Building 4130 • Room 130.02.14
+49 (0) 6221 54 15260
klassische-indologie@uni-heidelberg.de